Common Mistakes When Buying an Urn (And How to Avoid Them)

Choosing a cremation urn is often something families have never done before. During an emotional time, it can be easy to focus on appearance alone and overlook practical details that may affect your long-term satisfaction with the memorial.
The good news is that most common urn-buying mistakes are easy to avoid with a little guidance.
This guide highlights some of the most common mistakes families make when purchasing a cremation urn and offers practical tips to help you make a confident and informed decision.

Mistake #1: Choosing the Wrong Size

The most common mistake is purchasing an urn without checking its capacity.
Many people assume all urns are the same size, but capacities vary significantly.
A simple guideline is:
One pound of body weight equals approximately one cubic inch of urn capacity.
Example:
Body Weight
Recommended Capacity
150 lbs
150 cubic inches
180 lbs
180 cubic inches
220 lbs
220 cubic inches

 

When uncertain, choosing a slightly larger urn is generally recommended.

Mistake #2: Focusing Only on Appearance

A beautiful urn is important, but appearance should not be the only consideration.
Before purchasing, think about:
  • Where the urn will be displayed
  • Whether it will be buried
  • Long-term durability
  • Capacity requirements
  • Family preferences
The best urn combines beauty with practicality.

Mistake #3: Not Considering Home Display

Many families plan to keep a cremation urn at home.
However, some buyers forget to consider:
  • Shelf space
  • Room décor
  • Visibility preferences
  • Display location
An urn that complements your home often feels more natural and comforting over time.

Mistake #4: Overlooking Keepsake Urns

Some families assume all ashes must remain together.
Today, many families choose:
  • One full-sized urn
  • Several keepsake urns
  • Memorial jewelry
This allows multiple family members to maintain a personal remembrance.
Keepsake urns are particularly helpful when relatives live in different locations.

Mistake #5: Not Discussing Options With Family

Memorial decisions often affect multiple people.
Before purchasing an urn, it can be helpful to discuss:
Topic
Why It Matters
Ashes sharing
Family preferences
Home display
Location decisions
Memorial style
Personal meaning
Keepsake options
Shared remembrance
Scattering plans
Long-term wishes

 

A simple conversation can help avoid misunderstandings later.

Mistake #6: Choosing the Wrong Material

Different urn materials offer different benefits.
- Metal Urns
Durable and suitable for long-term display.
- Wood Urns
Warm, natural, and timeless.
- Ceramic Urns
Decorative and artistic but may require extra care.
- Keepsake Jewelry
Allows a small symbolic amount of ashes to be carried close.
Consider both appearance and intended use before choosing a material.

Mistake #7: Forgetting About Keepsake Jewelry

Many people focus exclusively on urns and overlook Keepsake jewelry.
For family members who want a more personal connection, cremation jewelry can be a meaningful option.
Popular choices include:
  • Keepsake necklaces
  • Ash pendants
  • Bracelets
  • Keepsake charms
These pieces allow memories to remain close throughout everyday life.

Mistake #8: Rushing the Decision

Grief often creates pressure to make decisions quickly.
While some arrangements may have time constraints, choosing a memorial urn does not always need to be rushed.
Take time to consider:
  • Style preferences
  • Family wishes
  • Memorial goals
  • Long-term display plans
The right memorial often becomes clear when you allow yourself time to reflect.

Mistake #9: Choosing Based Solely on Price

Price matters, but value matters more.
A memorial urn is often intended to become a lasting tribute.
Instead of asking:
"What is the cheapest urn?"
Consider:
"Which urn feels most meaningful and appropriate?"
Many families find that emotional connection becomes more important than price over time.

Mistake #10: Forgetting the Person Behind the Memorial

Perhaps the most important mistake is focusing entirely on the product and forgetting the individual being remembered.
The most meaningful memorials often reflect:
  • Personality
  • Values
  • Interests
  • Favourite colours
  • Hobbies
  • Life experiences
An urn should feel personal, not generic.

Questions to Ask Before Buying an Urn

Before making a decision, consider:
- Is the capacity correct?
- Will it be displayed at home?
- Do family members want keepsake urns?
- Would memorial jewelry be meaningful?
- Does the style reflect the person being remembered?
- Is the material suitable for long-term use?
If the answer is yes to these questions, you're likely on the right track.

Final Thoughts

Buying a cremation urn is not something most people do often, which is why questions and uncertainty are completely normal.
By understanding the most common mistakes and taking time to consider both practical and personal factors, families can choose a memorial that provides comfort and meaning for years to come.
At DIY Funeral Products, we believe remembrance should be thoughtful, personal, and reflective of a life well lived. Taking a little extra time when choosing an urn can help create a tribute that truly honours someone special.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be considered funeral, legal, or professional advice.
Back to blog